Severing the Ebola Hydra's Head

Yesterday it was announced that two states--New York and New Jersey--are instituting a mandatory quarantine for healthcare workers returning from treating Ebola-stricken patients in West Africa. This quarantine was fueled by the panic engendered by the diagnosis of Ebola in Dr. Craig Spencer and not by any scientific basis regarding its efficacy.

There are several points to consider regarding this unwarranted quarantine:

1. Ebola is not contagious during its incubation period and when contagious is so only via contact with blood and body fluids. Those in the incubation period of Ebola pose no risk to others.

2. Healthcare workers in these states are already self-monitoring themselves for signs/symptoms of illness as well as subject to active surveillance by the local health departments. What added benefit will the quarantine have other than to assuage and validate panic? 

3. Such a quarantine basically will have a stultifying effect on those from New York and New Jersey who want to travel to ground zero to fight this virus at its source since they will be subject to a 21-day quarantine upon return, irrespective of symptoms.

The basic fact about this outbreak, often lost in the shuffle is that, akin to an actual war, taking the battle to the homeland of the aggressor is the only way to remove this risk. On that front, we suffered a major setback with Ebola's incursion into Mali. Just like Sherman's march on the South and Scipio Africanus' victory in Carthage, the immortal head of this Hydra must be severed in Africa.

A Week of Birthday Presents from Ebola

My wish list

This week I celebrated my 39th birthday and though I got formal presents (none of which are pictured, but my cake and Petri dish cookie is), Ebola continued to "bless" us all with new gifts, including the 2nd Texas healthcare worker's infection and her unfortunate CDC-sanctioned travel.

As I argued in my recent Time op-ed, these healthcare worker infections in the US provide incontrovertible evidence that not every hospital is prepared to deal--as they should be--with all aspects of an Ebola patient's care. This evidence was not something I welcomed as I had been someone who was completely convinced Ebola would not have secondary spread within the US. This shattered belief of mine stemmed from the history of uneventful importations of Lassa Fever, Marburg, and MERS. 

That healthcare workers who cared for the critically ill Thomas Eric Duncan are the ones who were  infected, as opposed to his circle of direct contacts who are about to complete their quarantine periods, argues that the modern ICU environment, with its tubes, invasive procedures, and central venous lines, is a terrain that Ebola has found conducive to its spread. It may be the case that in ordinary (i.e. non-critical) cases of hospitalization, Ebola may be stymied.

This is a virus that remains less contagious than many others and has a restrained ability to spread between humans, save to caregivers (healthcare workers or others). However, the virus has evolved to exploit any lapse in the barrier precautions employed by those who are in its midst. These lapses can not occur for this is an unforgiving virus.

The first priority in ensuring that additional healthcare worker infections do not occur is to:

The cookie is a Petri dish of different bacteria

1. Stop this outbreak at its source--the head of the hydra is in West Africa and that is where the battle must be waged aggressively. The recently leaked WHO document illustrates how a gross initial underestimation of the outbreak's potential for spread in West Africa allowed this outbreak to fester longer and gain an incredible head start that transformed later interventions into mere squirt guns in the face of a raging forest fire.

2. Treat any additional imported or healthcare worker cases in the biocontainment facilities at the NIH, Emory, and Nebraska. Though scarce, these facilities have proved their adeptness at handling Ebola cases safely. This should be our 1st tier and hopefully will be able to absorb what will only be a trickle of imported cases.

3. Designate additional facilities in every region of the US that have some capacity to care for Ebola patients safely and can be used as 2nd tier facilities. These facilities must be thoroughly educated, drilled, and prepared to handle Ebola patients. Protocols and passive education will not be enough.

4. Dampen the panic that is now, understandably, widespread amongst the public through concise, clear communication based on scientific facts. Ruling out Ebola in every vomiting frat boy is unproductive and a poor use of resources.

5. Determine what the role of invasive interventions on Ebola patients should be going forward. It is likely that early recognition and treatment of Ebola patients with aggressive fluid resuscitation is essential and possibly able to forestall the dire complications that Mr. Duncan suffered. Is the benefit of such procedures as dialysis and mechanical ventilation outweighed by the risk to healthcare workers? Do such procedures actually improve outcomes? 

All our actions to stop Ebola must be thoroughly informed by the facts and instantaneously integrated with any and all new discoveries that emerge. By facing this pathogen with active minds--mankind's ultimate resource and game-changer--it will be stopped.

Some Questions About the 2nd case of Ebola diagnosed in the US

A few important details regarding the healthcare worker who cared for Mr. Duncan will be key to interpreting the transmission that occurred:

• Was this healthcare worker part of the 10 definite direct contacts or 38 possible direct contacts that were being monitored? (We know 7 healthcare workers were included in the 10)
• Was this healthcare involve, at all, with the care delivered during Mr. Duncan's 1st visit to the emergency department during which Ebola was not suspect and no isolation of him was performed? 

Ebola requires meticulous attention to infection control procedures--often something easier said than done--and clearly poses disparate risks to the healthcare worker and general populations. Presumably this healthcare worker, who developed fever and hence became symptomatic and contagious on Friday evening, was immediately isolated delimiting those with direct contact.

Will Ebola Panic Sever the Chain of Survival for Cardiac Arrest?

The #1 killer of Americans is not Ebola.

It is heart disease. The fact that heart has that distinct honor in 2014 is a testament to the fact that medicine has tamed many of the world's infectious diseases through hygiene, sanitation, antimicrobials, and vaccines. 

One of the key aspects of decreasing the mortality associated with coronary artery disease is prompt initiation of bystander CPR during witnessed cardiac arrest. This is the second link in the Chain of Survival. Getting prompt CPR can make a substantial difference not only in terms of survival but also in ultimate neurological recovery (i.e. minimizing injury to the brain secondary to oxygen deprivation).

As Ebola panic envelopes the world, "Ebola Scares" are popping up all over. In some cases people might collapse and provoke panicked bystanders to assume that the person's condition is due to Ebola--irrespective of the actual minuscule prevalence of the disease outside of the epidemic zone.  

Such reactions, if they dissuade bystander CPR (which is a strong possibility), will sever one of the crucial links in the cardiac arrest Chain of Survival.

Faulty risk perception is a puzzling thing that, in some cases, could have fatal secondary consequences.

A Plague of Misinformation on NCIS: New Orleans

There's been a lot of criticism of the media during infectious disease outbreaks (current and past) about over-sensationalistic rhetoric that foments fear. However, a recent episode of the television program NCIS: New Orleans really breaks new ground in spreading misinformation. 

In the show's latest episode, a navy shipman is found dead of plague and sparks a major investigation. During the course of the show, a litany of misinformation is presented. Some of the inaccuracies:

• Plague in a dead body doesn't isn't particularly contagious to people who haven't even touched the body
• Plague is not unknown to the United States. In fact, cases are diagnosed every year
• There is no vaccine available for plague
• It only requires droplet/contact precautions; not space suits

When Hollywood portrays infectious disease outbreaks with brazen errors (widely known to be false), it is understandable that the general public has myriad questions during real outbreaks.

When there are plenty of actual insoluble infectious disease problems to focus on why does Hollywood need to fabricate erroneous scenarios?